Dark Academia: Acknowledging the Privilege and Problems
Dark academia is a cultural movement that romanticizes a scholarly, Gothic lifestyle. Think of ivy-covered halls, worn leather-bound books, writing with quills, and debating philosophy by candlelight. It’s not just about fashion or decor; it’s a lifestyle centered on the love of learning, self-improvement, and the arts. While it offers a compelling and nostalgic escape, we need to recognize both its charm and its underlying issues.
The Allure of Dark Academia
The dark academia aesthetic evokes a sense of timelessness and intellectual pursuit. Imagine being immersed in classic literature, history, and philosophy, fostering a sense of intellectual curiosity and appreciation for the humanities. This aesthetic appeals to those who yearn for a connection to a bygone era where knowledge and learning were presumably revered, at least moreso than they are today.
In our fast-paced, digital age, dark academia provides us with a retreat. There's something inherently comforting about the slow, deliberate pace it promotes. Whether it's the act of reading a physical book, writing in a journal, or simply sitting in a cozy, dimly lit room, the aesthetic encourages us to slow down and savor these moments. It’s a response to the constant bombardment of information and stimuli we face daily.
Escapism from Rising Anti-Intellectualism
Today, dark academia also serves as a form of escapism from rising anti-intellectualism. The arts and humanities are under attack, and science denial is on the rise. People increasingly believe that opinions and sincerely held beliefs are equal to facts, devaluing education and critical thinking. Hopefully, and unfortunately, this isn’t something I should need to illustrate with examples.
There is also an alarming trend of book bans and censorship in schools across the United States. In states like Texas and Florida, there have been efforts to remove books that tackle subjects like race, gender, and sexuality from school libraries and curriculums. This not only restricts students' access to diverse perspectives but also undermines the critical thinking skills that education is supposed to foster.
Stepping away from pop culture and social media provides a break from the constant barrage of hateful rhetoric. In the quiet of a dimly lit room, surrounded by the smell of old books and the soft scratch of a pen on paper, one can find solace. This retreat into a world where learning and intellectual pursuit are celebrated offers comfort and a reminder of the intrinsic value of knowledge.
The Problems Within Dark Academia
Despite its many positive aspects, dark academia has flaws. It’s often criticized for its lack of diversity and inclusivity, centering on Eurocentric, white, and elite experiences while excluding marginalized communities and their histories. Academia and its institutions are still predominantly white, linked with straight, white, Christian colonialism and patriarchy. This reality is something to acknowledge and address within the movement.
The romanticization of rigorous academic environments can also overlook the stress, mental health issues, and unrealistic expectations that come with them. The pressure to achieve academic excellence and the glorification of “hustle culture” can lead to burnout and other mental health challenges. The dark side of academia, including the competitive and often toxic environment, is something that needs to be recognized. It’s important to remember that while the aesthetic can be beautiful, the reality of academic life can be grueling.
Recognizing Privilege
Engaging with dark academia means recognizing the privilege it represents. The movement often idealizes access to prestigious education and resources not available to everyone. Many people can’t afford to go to college. In the U.S., those who do face burdensome student loan debt that affects their quality of life. This makes academia something odd to romanticize, yet the desire to learn feels like a dream or fantasy, especially as basic public education is dismantled and books are banned by authoritarian ideologues.
Consider the recent debates over student loan forgiveness in the United States. The fact that so many people are burdened by student debt to the point where it becomes a national issue speaks volumes about the accessibility of higher education. The romanticized image of academia does not account for the financial strain and barriers many face in pursuing higher education.
Recognizing this privilege is crucial for fostering a more inclusive and thoughtful engagement with dark academia. It involves being mindful of broader socio-economic and cultural contexts and ensuring that the pursuit of knowledge and appreciation for the arts does not marginalize others.
The Joy of Learning for Its Own Sake
There was a time when education was seen as an end unto itself. “Learning how to learn” and developing critical thinking skills are invaluable. The arts and humanities teach compassion and empathy, enriching our understanding of the human experience.
The capitalist focus on learning in the hopes of finding high-paying jobs is another trend that dark academia rebels against. It revels in the joy of learning for its own sake, something that can be done in one's cozy space without attending a university. This aesthetic celebrates the intrinsic value of knowledge, encouraging a return to a time when intellectual pursuit was revered.
Moving Towards Inclusivity
To make dark academia more inclusive, we need to broaden its scope. This can be achieved by incorporating diverse voices, literatures, and experiences into the narrative. Highlighting scholars, authors, and historical figures from various backgrounds can enrich the movement and make it more representative. Read broadly. Listen to music beyond Eurocentric classical. Embrace art from across cultures, without fetishizing or appropriating it.
Creating spaces where everyone feels welcome to share their intellectual pursuits and artistic expressions is essential. Encouraging discussions about the challenges within academic environments and promoting mental health awareness can also help address some of the more problematic aspects of the movement.
The Role of Public Education
Public education in the United States is facing significant challenges. From underfunding to political interference, the very foundation of accessible education is under threat. For instance, in states like Florida, laws restricting discussions on race and gender in classrooms have sparked nationwide debates. These actions undermine the purpose of education, which is to foster critical thinking and expose students to a variety of viewpoints.
In this context, the dark academia aesthetic can be seen as a form of quiet rebellion. It champions the idea of learning for learning’s sake, a notion that is increasingly under threat. By celebrating intellectual pursuits outside the constraints of formal education systems, dark academia offers an alternative space where knowledge and curiosity are valued.
A Personal Reflection
For me, dark academia is more than just an aesthetic; it’s a reminder of what education should be. It’s about the joy of discovering new ideas, the thrill of intellectual debate, and the satisfaction of understanding complex concepts. It’s a rejection of the idea that knowledge is only valuable if it leads to a high-paying job. It’s an attempt to reconnect with my own humanity after having my soul shredded by corporate work environments and the endless call to blind consumerism.
When I step into my little study nook, surrounded by books and soft lighting, I feel a sense of peace. It’s a space where I can escape the chaos of the outside world and immerse myself in the beauty of learning. It’s a place where I can explore different philosophies, lose myself in literature, and simply enjoy the process of thinking.
TLDR
Dark academia offers a fascinating and enriching aesthetic that celebrates the pursuit of knowledge and the beauty of a scholarly life. However, it’s crucial to engage with it critically, acknowledging the problems and privileges it encompasses. By striving for inclusivity and recognizing the diverse experiences that contribute to the world of academia, we can create a more thoughtful and welcoming community for all.
Like any cultural movement, it is continually evolving. As we navigate its complexities, let’s do so with a commitment to inclusivity, awareness, and a genuine love for learning. Embracing this aesthetic provides a refuge from a world increasingly hostile to intellectualism and a reminder of the timeless value of knowledge and the arts.
Let’s cherish the quiet moments with our books and thoughts, finding joy in the pursuit of wisdom and beauty. And as we do, let’s also work to make this cherished world of dark academia a place where all can find inspiration and belonging. By broadening our perspectives and embracing diversity, we can enrich our understanding and make the world of dark academia more inclusive and representative of all those who seek solace and inspiration in the pursuit of knowledge.
I hope you're doing well today.
